The three scholars Geneva is about to hear about
On Thursday, a conference at the United Nations in Geneva closes with three men who lived more than a thousand years ago, all from the same stretch of Central Asia. Each is still read, quoted and argued over today. Here is who they were.
The conference at the UN Office at Geneva on 22 October carries a long title: Islamic civilisation, the great spiritual and scholarly heritage of Mawarannahr, and the horizons of enlightenment. Most of the afternoon belongs to the present: welcome speeches, a keynote from the director of the Islamic Civilization Center in Uzbekistan, talks on the Centre's future. The final block belongs to the ninth and tenth centuries. Three scholars, three short films, and three talks given by senior figures from the research centres that Uzbekistan has built in their names. All three were born within a little over forty years of one another in Mawarannahr, the old Arabic name for the land “beyond the river”, the Amu Darya, which takes in Bukhara, Samarkand and Termez.
Al-Bukhari, who threw almost everything away
Muhammad al-Bukhari was born in Bukhara in 810 and died in 870 in Khartank, a village near Samarkand where his mausoleum stands today. His life's work was a problem of verification. Sayings attributed to the Prophet Muhammad circulated in enormous numbers, carried from teacher to pupil along chains of named transmitters, and not all of them could be trusted.
Al-Bukhari's answer was ruthless selection. By the traditional account he examined some 600,000 narrations and kept 7,563, a figure that falls below 3,000 once repetitions are removed. The result, completed around 846 and known simply as the Sahih ("the sound"), is regarded by Sunni scholars as the most authentic book after the Qur'an itself. What the conference programme highlights is not piety but method: reliable knowledge, and the scholar's responsibility for what he passes on.
Al-Tirmidhi, the pupil his teacher learned from
Muhammad ibn Isa al-Tirmidhi was born in 824 near Termez, in what is now the far south of Uzbekistan, and died there in 892. He travelled to Khorasan, Iraq and the Hejaz to collect material, and he studied under al-Bukhari, citing him more than a hundred times in his own great collection, the Jami'. That book became one of the six canonical hadith collections of Sunni Islam, valued in particular for its attention to the discrepancies between reports and the people who transmitted them.
The relationship ran both ways. Al-Bukhari is reported to have told his student that he had benefited more from al-Tirmidhi than al-Tirmidhi had from him, and he included two of his pupil's narrations in his own Sahih. Later biographers record that al-Tirmidhi went blind in the last years of his life, and attribute it to grief, among other causes, at his teacher's death.
Al-Maturidi, who made room for reason
Abu Mansur al-Maturidi was born around 853 in Maturid, a district of Samarkand, and died in the city in 944, aged about ninety. Where the other two worked on the reliability of what had been handed down, he worked on how to think about it. The school of theology that carries his name is one of the three principal schools of Sunni belief, and its defining habit is to give reason real weight alongside revelation, with an emphasis on human freedom and responsibility.
It travelled far beyond Samarkand. Maturidi theology became the preferred school of both the Ottoman and the Mughal empires, and it is still followed across Turkey, Central Asia, South Asia and the Balkans. The Geneva programme frames his legacy as a philosophy of tolerance and moderation, and it is easy to see why that is the inheritance Uzbekistan chooses to emphasise.
Why bring them to Geneva
Put the three side by side and the choice of venue makes sense. A scholar who demanded a standard of evidence before accepting a claim. A teacher who is remembered for telling his own student that he had learned more from him than the other way round. A theologian who insisted that reason has a place inside faith. These are habits a city built around verification and negotiation already recognises, and they come, perhaps unexpectedly, from three towns on the old roads of Central Asia.
That is the case Uzbekistan is making in Geneva this week: that the region's heritage is not only monuments and manuscripts, but a way of reasoning that has been in continuous use for more than eleven hundred years.
Comments ()